This blog is authored by VSTE's Certified Coach Program Coordinator, Katie Breaud
My second year of teaching didn’t start off great. I was returning to the same role, but the coaches in our building were brand new. The previous year I had built an amazing relationship with my instructional coach, and I assumed one of the new coaches would be able to pick up where we left off. Not quite. Due to scheduling conflicts we weren’t able to meet until the sixth week of school, so I asked them to help me with my SMART goals. They jumped in feet first! I was inundated with book study ideas, instructional strategies to try, and a draft of how I could fill in the school division’s template. I left the meeting feeling overwhelmed and unheard.
Looking back, I can empathize with those coaches. Although they were new to me, they were veteran coaches that knew what types of goals a teacher in my position should pursue (and the resources that would go along with them). Sometimes, as coaches, we feel pressure to act and to help. It’s in our nature. What we need to remember is that the real power lies in simply listening first.
Why Trust Comes Before Change
There is a reason why Domain 1 of Forward Edge’s Core of Coaching Framework is Building Relationships. How many times have we heard, “Maslow’s before Bloom’s”? Just like the students in our classrooms, teachers also need to feel psychologically safe before they can experiment, reflect, or grow. Active listening has a multi-pronged impact on building this foundation. It models empathy, creates space for honest dialogue, and affirms teachers as individuals with specific needs.
Three Coaching Practices That Center Trust
- Lead with curiosity instead of solutions: Approach each challenge with an open mind (and ear). It is easy to jump to conclusions when you hear a problem that you have previously solved. Avoid offering a strategy or tech tool too soon before you understand the scope of the issue. Ask questions such as, “Can you tell me more about your goal?” or “What is working well for you right now?”
- Normalize Emotional Honesty: Verbally acknowledge the feelings in the room. It is okay to recognize when a situation is overwhelming or if there is ambiguity in the system. One comment to try is, “You’re not alone. Lots of teachers are feeling that way right now, too. Let’s figure this out together.”
- Honor Teacher Autonomy & Voice: Use a coaching version of the looping strategy! Reiterate what you hear the teacher say and ask if you heard them correctly. Ask follow-up questions to ensure you fully understand their perspective. This allows them the opportunity to clarify their intentions while validating their expertise. Looping has been shown to promote understanding and empathy, two pillars of trust.
Tying This to the VSTE Certified Coach (VCC) Program
VCCs are trained to listen deeply, lead with empathy, and recognize each educator as an individual. These aren’t just nice-to-have “soft skills”! In order to create systemic and sustainable change, there needs to be a foundation of trust. Also keep in mind that even if a teacher isn’t “ready” for coaching (yet), building relationships is coaching!
Tools Coaches Can Use
- Try Elena Aguilar’s Coaching Sentence Stems as open-ended prompts to deepen reflection and build rapport
- Use or create a digital check-in for ongoing pulse checks
- Suggestion: Try this one from SchoolAI
- Incorporate a thinking routine into your own practice such as “See, Think, Wonder” or the “Ladder of Inference”
- Learn more about the intersection of Maslow’s & Coaching with this blog post from Brooke Conklin
Coaching Reflection Prompt
What is one way you can build trust with a hesitant teacher this fall?
This post is part of a monthly series inspired by the VSTE Certified Coach program and the Core of Coaching Framework, designed to support and grow coaches across Virginia.
Transparency Statement: This blog post was co-developed with support from an AI writing assistant (ChatGPT). The author retains full creative control and authorship of the post content. AI was used to brainstorm ideas, organize outlines, and review grammar and spelling.